Four Novembers ago, Georgia State came to Huntington for Marshall's Senior Day and went up 10-0. Then Khalan Laborn broke an 83-yard touchdown run, and the Herd came back to win 28-23 on the day Marshall honored 21 seniors. The Panthers are back for another one. Saturday is Senior Day again at Joan C. Edwards Stadium, part of Marshall's "Salute to Service" game, with a West Virginia Air National Guard flyover during the anthem and fans asked to wear white. The teams arrive with identical records, 5-5 overall and 2-4 in the Sun Belt Conference, and each needs one more win to reach six.
Marshall let one get away last Saturday. The Herd led App State 13-3 in the second quarter after two Jorge Diaz Nicolas field goals, one from 54 yards, and TJ Lester's 2-yard run. They outrushed the Mountaineers 210 to 186, with Jo'Shon Barbie going for 108 yards on 17 carries and quarterback Carlos Del Rio-Wilson adding 66. But App State went ahead 20-16 early in the fourth quarter, and Marshall's last three possessions all ended on fourth down, one of them at the App State 19 with 3:11 left. It was a second straight loss, after a 49-13 defeat at Georgia Southern.
Georgia State's rivalry game at home started well and ended badly. The Panthers led Georgia Southern 14-7 after one quarter, scored every one of their points off three Eagle turnovers, and still lost 34-17. Georgia Southern outgained them by more than 200 yards and sacked Ayden Pereira four times. A week earlier, the Panthers had won 39-23 in Boone by running for 265 yards and sacking App State's quarterbacks six times, so the formula is there when it works.
The quarterback question belongs to Georgia State. Cameran Brown, who threw 14 touchdown passes in his seven games, was hurt in the second quarter at Arkansas State on Oct. 24 and hasn't played since. He was ruled out for Georgia Southern, and his status for Marshall hadn't been reported when this was written. Pereira has started the last three games and is 1-2. Marshall's quarterback is Del Rio-Wilson, who threw 22 of the Herd's 26 passes against App State. Zion Turner started at quarterback in October and is also on hand.
The first matchup to watch is Georgia State's running game against Marshall's run defense. Lanear McCrary Jr. and Qwantavius Wiggins have each run for more than 500 yards, and the Panthers run the ball as well as anyone in the league. Marshall has given up about five yards a carry this season, and only South Alabama's defense allows more yards per play in the Sun Belt. If McCrary and Wiggins get going, Pereira doesn't have to win the game with his arm.
The second is Georgia State's pass rush. Xavier Esqillion has 10 sacks, and Jabriel Rhodes-Nelson has six, which gives the Panthers one of the most disruptive fronts in the conference. Marshall will want to keep Del Rio-Wilson moving and lean on a deep backfield, with Barbie, Judah Price, Khalil Wilkins and Lester all capable of carrying the load. The Herd have had trouble holding on to the ball, though, and Georgia State's defense has been good at getting off the field on third down.
The stakes don't end Saturday, but the paths after it aren't equal. Marshall closes at ULM on Nov. 28, against a Warhawks team that is 2-8. Georgia State finishes against Louisiana, which is already bowl eligible. The winner here gets to six with a week to spare. The loser's final shot looks very different depending on which side of the field it stands on.
Marshall leads the series 3-1 and has won both meetings in Huntington, the 2022 comeback and a 35-20 win on a Thursday night in 2024. Georgia State's only win came in Atlanta in 2023, 41-24. The Herd also won last year's game at Center Parc, 30-18.
The projection is Georgia State 27, Marshall 21. The Panthers have the better offense per play and the better defense, and their running game fits what Marshall has struggled to stop. Brown's absence takes some of the edge off, since Pereira hasn't been nearly as efficient through the air, which is why this stays a one-score game. Marshall at home on Senior Day, with a run game of its own, is the reason it isn't wider.
The market, for the record: no line had been posted when this was written.
What breaks it: Marshall's backs do to Georgia State what they did to App State, Del Rio-Wilson keeps drives alive with his legs, and the Herd finish the drives they didn't finish last Saturday. The other way it breaks: Brown is cleared to play, the Panthers' pass rush takes over, and Georgia State pulls away the way it did in Boone.